Which Seed Starting Mix is Best?

Updated: January 13, 2020

I used to make my own seed starting mix. No more! Don’t get me wrong. Seed starting soil is very important to the success of your seedlings. It’s important enough that you might want to completely control the process and make your own.

One year I bought a bad batch of mix, and my seedlings turned out awful. In fact, they were so bad that I couldn’t use them and ended up buying seedlings from a nursery.

Still, mix is so inexpensive, easy and fast to buy online, it doesn’t really make sense to mix your own anymore. It’s cheaper and also better to have the professionals make it, rather than buy the ingredients in bulk and do it yourself.

So, to help make sure you don’t get a bad product (as I did), I’ve conducted an unbiased test of the four top seed starting mixes. Here’s what I learned:

Let’s take a sec to get the legal words out of the way. This article may contain affiliate links. That means if you click and buy from my partners, I will make a tiny amount of money at no cost to you. This in no way affects my recommendations.

The Best Seed Starting Mix …

If you don’t want all the details and just want to know which one is best, it’s Burpee Seed Starting Mix!

All the seeds planted in Burpee sprouted as fast or faster than the others, and the seedlings were more vigorous than the others.

However, Burpee did not perform well when using a soil block maker. The mix did not hold together well enough for blocks. If you are going to make soil blocks, the best product is the Promix. It held together very well and was almost as good as the Burpee mix in my test.

Now that the secret is blown, read on to learn about the details.

Test Criteria

I conducted the test by looking at the top four OMRI listed organic products:

• Burpee Seed Starting Mix
• Black Gold Seedling Mix
• Sprout Island Blend Organic Seed Starter
• Promix Organic Pro Seed Starting Mix

Why OMRI listed products only? OMRI (Organic Materials Review Institute) reviews products to make sure they are acceptable for certified organic production.

I can see how some people could disagree with this criteria. After all, seed starting soil ingredients probably are pretty clean.

But I want my food to be the very best, healthiest food possible. So OMRI listing is worth it to me.

I also decided to exclude products with vermiculate. Why? For two reasons:

1. Not all but some sources of vermiculate have been found to contain asbestos. No thank you!
2. Breathing in vermiculate makes me cough. I know this from working with it in the past.

No worries! In just about all cases, perlite is a good substitute for vermiculate.

Also, the manufacturers have included organic fertilizer in each of the products. While fertilizer may increase the chances of dampening off, I believe a little fertilizer helps the seedlings to have nutrients as soon as they need it. They shouldn’t have to wait for the grower to add liquid fertilizer.

Most importantly, I tested the following criteria for each of the organic seed starting mixes:

• When plants poked above the soil
• Which plants were most vigorous
• Which showed signs of dampening off

Finally, I think you should know that the products looked significantly different right out of the bag. They obviously are not all the same.

This was surprising to me because I expected a standard recipe for seed starting soil. Obviously, the experts differ on what works best.

Burpee Seed Starting Mix

Manufacturer: Burpee

Ingredients:

• Primarily coir (coconut fiber)
• Organic plant food (No details given)

Features & Benefits:

• Formulated for neutral pH, which is ideal for most plants
• Speeds plant and root growth
• Provides improved root aeration
• Certified safe for organic gardening (OMRI-listed)

Video:

Important details: Burpee is the best performer. The seeds in this mix sprouted first and were the most vigorous. Plus, there were absolutely no signs of dampening off.

Surprisingly, this mix has a more orange color when compared to the others. I expect that this is because it’s made primarily of coir. There seems to be no perlite as part of this recipe.

Unfortunately, Burpee Seed Starting Mix did not perform well when I used a soil block maker. The blocks didn’t hold together well. It was so bad that the blocks crumbled whenever I tried to move them.

If you are using a soil block maker, you should use Promix. It worked well with my soil block maker.

You can get more details, including pricing, on Burpee Mix here.

Promix Organic Pro Seed Starting Mix

Manufacturer: Premier Horticulture

Ingredients: 

• Canadian sphagnum peat moss
• Coir (coconut fiber)
• Perlite 
• Limestone
• Organic Fertilizer
• Mycorrhizae – PTB297 Technology

According to Premier Horticulture, mycorrhizae helps you in two ways. It:

1. Prevents diseases (such as dampening off)
2. Helps break down the organic fertilizer so the plants can use it sooner

Features & Benefits:

• Stimulate vigorous growth, strengthen roots, improve stress resistance and resist transplant shock
• Manages moisture levels and protects against root rot
• Feeds plants gradually for up to three months
• Certified safe for organic gardening (OMRI-listed)

Important details: This mix was the second best performer. It came very close to the Burpee.

The seeds in this soil sprouted immediately after the Burpee mix. Plus, the plants were almost as vigorous as the top performer. There were absolutely no signs of dampening off.

Soil blocks that I made with Promix held together well. I recommend this product if you are going to use a soil block maker.

You can get more details, including pricing, on Promix Mix here.

Sprout Island Blend Organic Seed Starter

Manufacturer: Cost of Maine

Ingredients:

• Blended sphagnum peat moss
• Perlite
• Nutrient starter (fertilizer) that includes mycorrhizae, kelp meal, worm castings and lobster meal

Features:

• Provides natural moisture retention and aeration
• Works well in cell packs or flats
• Creates a biologically diverse environment ideal for germinating seeds and rooting cuttings
• Certified safe for organic gardening (OMRI-listed)

Important details: Because I’m originally from the coast of Maine, and I’ve used Cost of Maine products for some time, I fully expected this mix to win. But it didn’t even come in second.

The seeds in this mix sprouted third and one seed never came up. The plants, however, were very vigorous. Still, they were somewhat behind Burpee and Promix.

You can get additional details, including pricing, on Sprout Island Blend Organic Seed Starter here.

Black Gold Seedling Mix

Manufacturer: Black Gold

Ingredients:

• 70 – 80% Canadian Sphagnum peat moss
• Perlite
• Yucca extract (organic wetting agent)
• RESiLIENCE(R) silicon dioxide (SiO2) from calcium silicate for resistance to wilting 

Features:

• Retains moisture yet drains well
• Enhances growth
• Resists plant wilting
• Certified safe for organic gardening (OMRI-listed)

Important details: I found Black Gold to be the worst performer.

Like Coast of Maine, one seed didn’t sprout. Plus, the ones that did were significantly less vigorous.

There was no dampening off, but at one point, it looked like there might be some plant loss. I do not recommend this seed starting mix.

You can get more details, including pricing, on Black Gold Seedling Mix here.

Summery

I was truly surprised by the outcome of this test. I did not expect Burpee to finish first.

But this is why unbiased testing is so important with nearly all gardening products.

Countless times I’ve purchased a plant from a nursery or seeds from a catalog or some other product, and it hasn’t performed as expected.

Anyway, I wish you good luck when starting your seeds.

Related articles you might enjoy:

1. Build an Indoor Seedling Starting Unit
2. Transplant Seedlings at Proper Soil Temperature
3. Getting Rid of Gnats on Seedlings

Suburban Hobby Farmer is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.